Head to Head
12 Gauge vs 20 Gauge
Maximum payload and versatility vs. lighter recoil and easier handling.
12 Gauge
Best for: Defense & all-around
- Most payload and load variety
- Best for home defense buckshot/slugs
- Ammo everywhere
- The do-everything standard
VS
20 Gauge
Best for: Recoil-sensitive & upland
- Noticeably less recoil
- Lighter to carry all day
- Great for smaller-framed shooters
- Plenty for defense and upland birds
The Verdict
12 gauge is the default for versatility and defense. A 20 gauge is an excellent choice for recoil-sensitive shooters and upland hunting — and a 20 with buckshot is still very capable for home defense.
Related Questions
88Votes
1Answers
Buckshot vs. birdshot for home defense - does it matter?
0Votes
1Answers
Rifled vs sabot slug — which for my shotgun?
0Votes
2Answers
Pump vs. semi-auto for home defense?
0Votes
2Answers
Best shotgun gauge if I am recoil-sensitive?
0Votes
2Answers
Bead vs. ghost-ring sights on a defense shotgun?
0Votes
1Answers
Is a 20 gauge enough for home defense?
0Votes
1Answers
Is a .357 Magnum revolver good for home defense?
0Votes
1Answers
Mossberg 500 or Remington 870 for a first shotgun?